Written by for a 1932 Yiddish musical that closed in a season; five years later the Andrews Sisters' English version became a worldwide hit — the Yiddish stage's greatest crossover.
Secunda and lyricist Jacob Jacobs wrote it for the 1932 Yiddish musical I Would If I Could (M’ken lebn nor m’lozt nit), which closed after one season in Brooklyn. In 1937 they sold the publishing rights for $30. That same year Sammy Cahn and Lou Levy heard two Black performers sing it in Yiddish at the Apollo; Cahn wrote English lyrics, and the Andrews Sisters cut it for Decca as a B-side. It became their first huge hit — and the Yiddish stage’s greatest crossover — while Secunda watched from Second Avenue.